In conversation with Emily Pentzer
Award-winning associate professor Emily Pentzer, Editor-in-Chief of RSC Applied Polymers, shares advice for authors.

Emily Pentzer
What makes a stand-out manuscript? In this interview, we asked award-winning associate professor Emily Pentzer, Editor-in-Chief of RSC Applied Polymers, to share the advice she would give to authors.
As well as learning the importance of crafting compelling titles and abstracts, highlighting real-world applications and responding to reviewer feedback, you鈥檒l also discover emerging trends in polymer science, tips for building your publication record, and why staying persistently curious can shape a successful research career.
As the Editor-in-Chief, what are the two or three most important qualities that make a new manuscript stand out when it first arrives on your desk?
When a new manuscript comes across my desk, one of the first things I notice is the title 鈥 is it engaging, or too detailed, or not detailed enough? The abstract should also be well written and thorough; these are the two things the readers will come across that tell them if they want to know more, and they need to be informative and of high quality.
RSC Applied Polymers focuses on practical, real-world applications of polymer science. How can researchers best present the applied significance of their work to make it more compelling to the journal's editors and readership?
We receive some submissions that are strong pieces of work, but focus on structure-property relationships and don鈥檛 necessarily talk about an application. If a new material is really tough, put it in the context of other polymers and what their application landscape is. The author can help the readers understand why their polymers are exciting, rather than leave it to the imagination.
In times of conflicting reviews, an email to the editor can help understand the path forward.
The peer review process can be challenging for authors. What are your key recommendations for responding to reviewer comments, especially when the feedback is critical or conflicting?
I always tell my students, 鈥渋f a reviewer had this confusion or critique then it鈥檚 likely a reader will as well.鈥 Sometimes it鈥檚 important to understand how confusion of a reviewer arose, and if it is simply a language change that is needed. It can be hard when reviewers either miss key points, or if two reviewers are in direct conflict with each other. In times of conflicting reviews, an email to the editor can help understand the path forward. If a review is highly critical, it鈥檚 always important to remember that it鈥檚 not personal and tone does not always come through in writing, taking a few days to digest the comments can help you think through what the basis of the criticism is.
Each manuscript should be its own story [鈥 my number one tip would be to have each presentation or publication stand on its own, as the audience or reader may not know much about the background.
Based on your own experience, what advice do you have for early-career researchers who are just starting to build their publication record? How can they strategically choose where and what to publish to maximise their impact?
I always think of the readership of the journal and what other types of work the journal has published. Reading the literature can help give insight into what type of work is published in which journals, especially for scope of the journal but also potential impact of the work. To maximise impact of your publication, it鈥檚 good to highlight them to broad audiences, either through social media or through resources at the home institution. In choosing what to publish, each manuscript should be its own story, and it鈥檚 important not to whittle down to the smallest publishable unit. For a manuscript, I like to ask myself what is the knowledge that is gained and who would be interested in it.
RSC Applied Polymers
RSC Applied Polymers is an open access journal offering you an impactful platform for the application of polymers, both natural and synthetic, including experimental and computational studies.
As a prominent voice in the field, what emerging research areas in polymer science are you most excited about right now? What kind of groundbreaking submissions would you love to see in RSC Applied Polymers in the next few years? And how do you stay up to date with new research and trends?
I think as a community we are going to start seeing broader impact of artificial intelligence in polymer science, including understanding structure-property-application relationships. If we can understand how the polymer behaves and changes under use, or over time/wear-and-tear, then we can design better ones. This could really have impact in the area of sustainability, the rapid development of new polymers, and the use of polymers in applications where we have typically relied on other materials.
For example, the Cameron group used , and the Sardon group used . I think we will continue to see growth in the use of polymers for biological mimics, such as mucin, as well as new ways to used polymers for energy management and separation of complex mixtures, such as recycling of batteries. I like to learn what areas other researchers are working in by scrolling through specific journals, or, if I鈥檓 lucky enough, sitting in a conference room in a symposium where I鈥檓 not familiar with the topic.
I love that polymer science can be applied across so many different areas.
What first drew you to polymer science, and what keeps you passionate about the field? Can you share a proud moment or breakthrough from your own research career?
I always thought I would do natural product synthesis as a PhD student because I really loved organic chemistry. But once I was introduced to polymers, I fell in love with the idea of using organic reactions to make polymers with different properties. With polymer science, we have the opportunity to combine synthesis and processing to control properties. One thing my group thinks a lot about right now is using the same polymer and using different printing conditions to vary mechanical and degradation properties. Further, my PhD work focused on making new polymers for drug delivery and my postdoc work focused on using polymers for solar energy harvesting; I love that polymer science can be applied across so many different areas and we have the opportunity to identify a problem, or an opportunity, and think about how to solve it, or at least better understand the challenge to solving it.
Hand picked by Emily: explore our inaugural year collection
To mark a year since the launch of RSC Applied Polymers, Emily has curated a collection of articles to give you immediate access to discoveries that could accelerate your next project, solve your toughest challenges, or spark your next innovation.
Where do you see both the field of applied polymers, and the journal, heading in the next decade?
In the next decade, RSC Applied Polymers will continue to serve the community through strong peer review protocols and will become the flagship journal for publishing work in the application of polymers. Natural polymers are abundant and synthetic polymers make modern life possible. My hope is that I can鈥檛 currently imagine all the ways in which polymers will play a role in enhancing human health and safety over the next decade, and that scientists and engineers work together to leverage the diverse expertise needed to design, develop, and apply polymers across biology, energy, and materials.
What are your top tips for effectively communicating research findings, both in publications and to a wider audience?
My number one tip would be to have each presentation or publication stand on its own, as the audience or reader may not know much about the background. Starting from fundamentals can help the audience and community understand your thought process and motivation, which will not only help educate researchers who are new to the field but also give the opportunity to think about collaborations.
It can be exciting to see how an idea grows and expands beyond what we were thinking yesterday.
Finally, if you could offer one single piece of career advice to a young researcher with a promising idea, what would it be?
My advice would be to remain persistently curious. Having a promising idea is a great feeling, and sometimes we (myself included) can hold too tightly to an idea rather than let that idea evolve with the collection of more information (or data). At conferences and seminars, show up and be engaged and it can be exciting to see how an idea grows and expands beyond what we were thinking yesterday.
Stay up to date with our journals
RSC Applied Interfaces
Interfacial and surface research with an applied focus
Open Access: Gold
Polymer 九州影院
The journal for the most innovative and exciting polymer chemistry, with an emphasis on the synthesis and properties of polymers.
Open Access: Hybrid
Journal of Materials 九州影院 A
Materials with applications in energy and sustainability
Open Access: Hybrid